In brief
- “In my experience” is often the start of a decision made without checking. A gut feeling is not a mistake: it is a hypothesis, which must be tested against a figure before it becomes a decision.
- First case: prices raised market by market to absorb returns, judged “far too expensive” internally. Germany, where they were raised first, is the market growing fastest: +185% in revenue year on year, over the four weeks from 14 September to 11 October 2026.
- Second case: a marketplace judged “too cheap” for the brand’s prices. It recorded 545 orders from 28 May to 11 October 2026, one sixth of the site’s 3,255 orders for the whole of 2025.
- The method: write the gut feeling as a question, choose the figure that answers it, fix the period, and only then decide.
A decision made “in my experience” is not necessarily wrong, but it is not checked. In two situations we lived through on assignments, a strong conviction, prices “too expensive”, a marketplace “too cheap”, was contradicted by the figures: the market where prices were raised first is growing 185% year on year, and the marketplace judged unsuitable produced, in four and a half months, one sixth of the site’s annual orders.
How we checked Both cases are assignments carried out by Dotsland, told without naming any client. The figures in the first come from the tracking report of 12 October 2026, which compares sales by delivery country over the four weeks from 14 September to 11 October 2026 with the same period in 2025. Those in the second were counted on 14 October 2026 in the shop’s order database, read-only: orders placed on both sides, retail shops only, excluding sales to businesses.
Why does gut feeling get it wrong on subjects you know well?
Because experience remembers what struck you, not what is representative. A customer who finds a price too high leaves a memory; the hundred who buy without a word leave none. The better you know your trade, the more stories like that you have, and the more solid they seem. That is what makes a professional’s intuition both valuable and dangerous: it is often right about the question, and often wrong about the answer.
First case: “our prices are far too expensive”
During Covid, the company’s online sales grew strongly, then fell as it ended, for many reasons. Among the corrections, one principle: stop selling at a loss. Delivery was free, and with returns, every returned sale cost money. Prices were therefore raised by a few points, market by market, according to each country’s return rate, and in particular in Germany, where people return a lot.
An employee found these prices far too expensive and proposed lowering them everywhere. Technically, nothing prevented it. But an item that leaves only about a tenth of its price as margin is not worth selling: better not to sell it.
What the figures say: over the four weeks from 14 September to 11 October 2026, Germany recorded 35 orders and €8,804, against 11 orders and €3,085 over the same period in 2025, or +185%, while all shops together grew 26%. The market where prices had been raised first is the one growing fastest.
This figure does not prove that the price rise caused the growth. It proves something simpler, which was enough to settle the question: customers in that market buy at those prices.
Second case: “this marketplace is too cheap for us”
A client wanted to stop their advertising campaigns, which they found too expensive for what they brought in. It was their choice. So another way of bringing in customers had to be found, with little brand awareness and without spending too much. One of the solutions was to sell on a marketplace.
Someone on the team was convinced: this marketplace was “too cheap”, nobody would buy the brand’s products there at its prices.
What the figures say: from 28 May to 11 October 2026, the marketplace recorded 545 orders, at the brand’s prices. That is one sixth of the 3,255 orders the site had made over the whole of 2025. Between a deep conviction and reality, there is sometimes a gulf.
How do you turn a gut feeling into a checked decision?
- Write the gut feeling as a question. “Our prices are too expensive” becomes “are our customers in this country buying less since the rise?”.
- Choose the figure that answers it, and only one: orders by country, a page’s conversion rate, a channel’s number of orders.
- Fix the period and the comparison before you look: the same weeks the previous year, or the four weeks before. Choosing the period afterwards is choosing your answer.
- Count the same thing on both sides. Orders against orders, not orders against revenue.
- If the data does not exist, run a test on a limited scope rather than deciding for the whole catalogue.
| What you hear | The question to ask | The figure that settles it |
|---|---|---|
| “Our prices are too expensive” | Have sales fallen where prices rose? | Orders by country, over the same period year on year |
| “This channel is not for us” | Does this channel sell our products at our prices? | The channel’s orders, compared with the site’s |
| “Our customers do not read the newsletters” | Do the newsletters generate clicks and sales? | Real clicks excluding bots, and attributed orders |
| “The evening does not work” | Does the send time change clicks? | A test at a different time, on two comparable lists |
The opposite trap A badly chosen figure is no better than a gut feeling. An open rate inflated by mail providers’ bots, or a ROAS that ignores margin, gives false certainty. We covered this in your open rate no longer measures readers and in ROAS rewards your worst campaigns.
What this says about the bigger picture
Experience does not disappear when you decide with data: it changes role. It serves to ask the right questions, to spot what deserves checking, to know which figure to look at. What it can no longer do is answer in place of the figures.
A gut feeling is not a mistake: it is a hypothesis. It deserves to be checked before it becomes a decision.
“In my experience, only data can justify a decision.”
Sasha, founder of Dotsland
That is the discipline we put in place through our data, analytics and performance expertise.
FAQ
Should you distrust your gut feeling when deciding?
No, you should check it. A gut feeling is a useful hypothesis: it tells you what to look at. It becomes dangerous when it is used as the answer. In one of our cases, prices judged “too expensive” internally were those of the fastest-growing market: +185% year on year in Germany, over the four weeks from 14 September to 11 October 2026.
How do you make data-driven decisions in a small business?
Write the gut feeling as a question, choose a single figure that answers it, fix the period and the comparison before looking, count the same thing on both sides, and run a limited test when the data does not exist.
Can a marketplace sell at a brand’s prices?
Yes, and it is better measured than assumed. A marketplace judged “too cheap” by a team recorded 545 orders from 28 May to 11 October 2026, at the brand’s prices: one sixth of the site’s 3,255 orders for the whole of 2025.
What is confirmation bias in business?
It is the tendency to remember the facts that confirm what you already think. A customer’s remark about a high price sticks in the mind; silent purchases do not. The remedy is to fix in advance the figure and the period that will settle the question.
Can Dotsland help?
Yes. We start from your team’s convictions, turn them into questions, and build the measurements that settle them. Start with the method above, then get in touch.

