← All articles

Know your margin product by product before you grow

An item on sale at €91 on its own site has to be listed at €190 on a German marketplace to avoid losing money. Margin per item kept, maximum discount and price reviews.

Dots Papers cover for the article on margin per product and per item kept, E-commerce section

In brief

  • Before opening a channel or a country, you need to know your margin product by product, calculated on the item kept and not on the item sold.
  • That margin includes every cost of a sale: commission, payment fees, outbound shipping, and returns, meaning return shipping and the share of items sent back.
  • On 19 October 2026 we simulated an item sold at €91 in the sales on its own site: on a German marketplace, it has to be listed at €190 just to avoid losing money, €250 to keep €30 of margin per item kept, and €360 for those €30 to hold after a 30% discount.
  • The starting price must therefore include, from the outset, the season’s maximum discount, and stay within the price range the channel accepts.
  • A margin is not set once: it is recalculated every month, every quarter and every six months, from the sales and returns actually measured.

Knowing your margin product by product means knowing, for each item and each channel, what is left once commission, payment fees, shipping and returns are paid. Without this calculation, a product that sells well can lose money on every order. In our example, an item on sale at €91 on its own site has to be listed at €190 on a German marketplace just to avoid losing money.

How we calculated On 19 October 2026 we simulated an item from an online shop we support, in the pricing tool we use for its marketplaces, read-only. The calculation uses the costs measured on that channel: commission, payment fees, outbound and return labels at the carrier’s rate and the item’s weight, and the return rate observed in Germany. The €91 price is the sale price shown that day on the site. No real margin figure for the shop is published here.

Why calculate margin on the item kept, not the item sold?

Because a returned item has cost money without bringing any in. It paid for outbound shipping, often return shipping, sometimes part of the commission and fees. Those costs have to be carried by the items customers keep. The higher a country’s return rate, the more each kept item has to absorb. We set out these costs in the real cost of returns, and the gaps between countries and channels in return rates by country and channel.

Which costs belong in a product’s margin?

All those a sale triggers, without exception:

  • the channel’s commission, often by price band on a marketplace;
  • payment fees;
  • outbound shipping, at the real rate and the item’s weight;
  • returns: return shipping and the share of returned items each kept item has to carry;
  • the purchase price of the product itself.

The rule that follows: a minimum margin per product, at least enough to pay for the product itself. You never sell at a loss. The commissions published by the main European marketplaces are gathered in our piece on what is really left after commission.

How much do you have to sell a €91 item for to avoid losing money on a marketplace?

If you sold this item on the marketplace at the site’s sale price, you would lose money very quickly. Take off a commission of about 20%, a little over 1% in payment fees, then outbound and return shipping for the items sent back: without even aiming for a 20 to 30% margin, you do not cover your costs. Here is what the calculation gives for Germany.

Goal Price to list on the marketplace
Sale price on the site €91
Simply not losing money €190
Keeping €30 and 20% margin per item kept €250
Keeping those €30 even after a 30% discount €360

The calculation does not only tell you which price to set. Sometimes it also tells you a product has no business on that channel.

How do you build sales and promotions in from the start?

By starting from the end. First calculate the maximum discount you will apply over the year or the season, sales and promotions included. Then set the starting price so the minimum margin still holds at that rate.

In our example, going from €250 to €360 is not a whim: it is the price a 30% discount requires if you want to keep the same €30 per item kept. Conversely, if the starting price is already set, the same calculation gives the maximum discount: the tipping point between a healthy business and a loss-making one. You know it before launching a promotion, not after.

The price must also stay within the channel’s range

This calculation now has one more constraint. Some marketplaces monitor price consistency: one of them can deactivate a product whose price is more than 20% above the average market price observed for that same product. The price is therefore no longer set only from its costs and its margin: it must also stay within a range the channel accepts. When the price that protects the margin falls outside that range, the product does not belong on that channel.

How to set up the calculation, product by product

  1. List your costs by channel and country: commission and its grid, payment fees, outbound and return label rates by weight.
  2. Measure the return rate by country and channel, or start from a cautious assumption while you have no sales.
  3. Set a minimum margin per item kept, in euros and as a percentage.
  4. Set the season’s maximum discount, then calculate the starting price that holds the margin at that discount.
  5. Check the channel’s range, and leave out the products that cannot fit into it.
  6. Recalculate on fixed dates: every month, every quarter and every six months.

The most common mistake Calculating margin on the item sold, at full price, without returns or discount. It is the most flattering figure and the most wrong: it leaves out precisely the costs that grow with sales. The same logic applies to advertising, as we explain in the POAS column in Google Ads.

What this says about the bigger picture

Opening a channel or a country multiplies sales, but also the costs each sale triggers. A business that grows without knowing its margin product by product can increase its revenue and lose more money on every order. Margin per item kept is not an accountant’s calculation: it is the condition for growing without getting poorer.

“Know your margin product by product before opening a channel. But above all, do not freeze it: review it every month, every quarter and every six months to update your prices. As soon as you have a few sales and a few returns, your prices can adjust continuously, from what you have actually measured rather than from a starting assumption.”

Sasha, founder of Dotsland

That is the work we do through our e-commerce and marketplaces expertise. To run the calculation yourself, our net margin per item kept simulator includes commission, shipping and returns.

FAQ

How do you calculate the net margin of a product sold on a marketplace?

Start from the price the customer pays, take off the commission, payment fees, outbound shipping, the share of returns each kept item has to carry, and the purchase price. The result is read per item kept, not per item sold.

Can you sell on a marketplace at the same price as on your own site?

Rarely without losing money. In our example of 19 October 2026, an item on sale at €91 on its own site has to be listed at €190 on a German marketplace just to cover commission, payment fees, shipping and returns.

How do I know how far I can cut my price in the sales?

By calculating the maximum discount: the steepest reduction the price can take before falling below your minimum margin per item kept. Better still, set that discount in advance and build the starting price so it holds: in our example, keeping €30 after a 30% discount requires €360 instead of €250.

How do I use margin data to reduce discount dependency in my catalogue campaigns?

First calculate each product’s margin per item kept, then group your products by margin level and by the maximum discount they can take. Products that cannot hold a discount should not go into promotional campaigns, and campaigns should be measured on margin, as with a POAS column.

How often should you review your prices?

On fixed dates: every month for adjustments, every quarter and every six months for substantive decisions. As soon as you have measured sales and returns, replace the starting assumptions with the real figures.

Can Dotsland help?

Yes. We build with you the margin calculation by product, channel and country, the season’s maximum discount and the price review points. Start with the list above, then get in touch.

Want to apply this to your own business?

Get in touch →

Further reading

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

12 − 11 =